Target stock continues to face challenges as major indexes make headway on Monday. Currently, the stock is down 3% at $119.40, marking a decline of over 6% since the beginning of the month and more than 20% for the year. This places Target’s shares dangerously close to their 52-week low, with the possibility of reaching their lowest close in over three years if they fall below $117.90.
It’s not just Target that is experiencing a decline in stock value today. The SPDR S&P Retail ETF (XRT) is also down 1.1%, and retail giant Walmart (WMT) is down 0.4%. However, Target’s performance has been worse compared to these peers.
The reason behind today’s downward movement is not immediately evident. While inflation has increased the prices of essentials, leading to a decrease in discretionary spending for many Americans, other discretionary retailers are actually trading higher today. Examples include Signet Jewelers (SIG) and TJX Cos. (TJX).
Interestingly, recent data released on Thursday shows that retail sales have continued to climb in August, defying cautious expectations. Some experts predict that the resumption of student loan repayments after the pandemic pause may further impact sales. However, this trend does not seem to be affecting Target’s peers today, although Target remains the primary concern in this regard.
While the cost of living remains high, it is likely that an increased number of consumers are resorting to shoplifting as a small five-finger discount. However, it is important to note that organized crime plays a much larger role in the surge of shoplifting incidents affecting various retailers. Target made headlines this spring when it brought attention to this problem, estimating a cost of half a billion dollars.
Furthermore, Target has found itself at the center of controversy surrounding the “war on woke.” Some of its employees faced threats of violence due to the Pride Month merchandise released in June. Nevertheless, companies involved in the anti-woke movement are experiencing mixed outcomes today.
In summary, Target stock is struggling amidst a broader retail downturn. Despite unclear reasons for the decline and positive retail sales data, Target’s shares continue to face downward pressure. Additionally, the company remains entangled in issues related to shoplifting and controversies surrounding social movements.
Walt Disney Stock Remains Steady
Disney’s stock (DIS) has shown little movement, while Anheuser-Busch InBev (BUD), the parent company of Bud Light, has seen a 1.2% increase. However, Kohl’s (KSS) and Adidas (ADDYY) have faced criticism for their Pride merchandise, resulting in a 3.9% and 2.2% drop, respectively.
Grocery Concerns Persist
Walmart recently issued a warning that while food prices may stabilize slightly, they will not return to pre-pandemic levels anytime soon. This news may be viewed positively for Walmart, as over 50% of their business comes from grocery sales. This will continue to generate substantial revenue and reduce the need for heavy discounting.
On the other hand, Target relies heavily on discretionary purchases. As long as consumers are forced to spend more on essential groceries, these discretionary purchases will likely take a back seat.
The Rise of Instacart
Instacart (CART) recently increased its initial public offering price in anticipation of its upcoming trading debut. However, some concerns linger in the background. Many supermarkets are introducing their own delivery services, including Walmart’s Walmart+ subscription program with added perks, as well as cheaper alternatives from companies like Kroger (KR). Target owns Shipt, a delivery service catering to its own and other stores. Some investors speculate that food retailers will need to actively compete against third-party players like Instacart.
A Combination of Concerns
Today’s lackluster performance in the stock market may be attributed to a combination of recent concerns. Despite raising its dividend and reporting strong earnings this summer, Disney remains a “show-me” story for investors as the pandemic’s peak has subsided, and numerous challenges are anticipated.